Patriotic Alternative running scared after trial reveals terrorist link

NOTE: This article was published on 21 November 2023 Costello – jailed for inciting racial hatred Mark Collett and Patriotic Alternative are running scared following the jailing last week of James Costello for multiple offences of inciting racial hatred. Costello, whom they are describing merely as “a member of our community” despite being a leading…

NOTE: This article was published on 21 November 2023

Costello – jailed for inciting racial hatred

Mark Collett and Patriotic Alternative are running scared following the jailing last week of James Costello for multiple offences of inciting racial hatred. Costello, whom they are describing merely as “a member of our community” despite being a leading member of the organisation, was sentenced to five years for 18 race hate charges and one of perverting the course of justice. But evidence was produced by the prosecution showing his links with a jailed nazi terrorist.

Costello was arrested after members of the public in Liverpool reported to the police stickers bearing the name ‘Creativity.com’ and saying, “Proud to be white?” which appeared on lamp posts in 2021. When police investigated the website it led them to Costello, and when they raided his home, they discovered large quantities of race hate material.

Costello professes to be a “reverend” in the so-called Creativity Movement, originally named the Church of the Creator, a notorious US-based white nationalist, antisemitic group established in 1973 by white supremacist Ben Klassen, who originated the idea of “racial holy war”. Its current leader Matt Hale is serving 40 years for attempting to incite the murder of a US federal judge.

Trying to distance themselves from Costello, PA are now whining that his offending predated him joining the organisation and had nothing to do with them. Though strictly speaking true, this skates over the fact that when he joined PA last year, he was already charged with eighteen race hate charges; they knew full well what he had been up to but were nevertheless quite happy to welcome him on board – and straight into the group’s leadership.

Costello (r) with PA leader Mark Collett at PA annual conference, October 2023

In fact, so highly regarded was he by PA’s leaders that he was allowed to address numerous public activities and in October was made chair (or ‘master of ceremonies’ as they put it) at their annual conference.

What is making them nervous now is evidence produced at his trial showing recent connections with National Action terrorist Jack Renshaw, currently serving life for plotting to murder Labour MP Rosie Cooper and threatening to kill a police officer.  Costello is known to have been involved with NA before it was banned, and to have trained with former members of the group at a “survival camp” in 2017, after the ban, but when he was raided by police they found more recent letters and postcards exchanged between him and Renshaw. This has upset PA leaders like Collett as it brings with it the prospect of further attention from the police and security services.

Mark Collett and other leading PA members were linked to NA before it was banned in 2016 under the Terrorism Act 2000. These former links have been a source of ongoing difficulty for PA, and anything which causes them to resurface makes the group very twitchy.

Only last June, Kris Kearns, also from Merseyside, a prominent PA and former National Action activist, was jailed for almost five years for terrorism offences. Kearns organised PA fitness clubs and online forums and contributed to Mark Collett’s many video streams and broadcasts.

Kris Kearns – five years for terrorism offences

In March, he admitted posting terrorist documents on his social media account, including the manifestos of mass murderers Anders Breivik and Brenton Tarrant.

When James Allchurch, another PA activist, was jailed earlier this year for inciting race hatred on his Radio Aryan podcast station, the prosecution pointed to the fact that one of the people he had interviewed was Mark Davies, a co-founder of National Action who got eight years in 2022 for secretly belonging to the group after it had been banned.

James Allchurch – hosted National Action terrorist.

Cases like these continue to underscore just what kind of organisation PA is: a natural home for violent white supremacists.


Professor Colin Holmes

Professor Colin Holmes
Everyone who wants to understand contemporary racism and its historical background needs to read Searchlight.
Professor Colin Holmes
University of Sheffield

Paul Holborow

Paul Holborow

In the campaign against the National Front, Searchlight provided a rich and utterly reliable basis for much ANL propaganda – particularly with reference to the two leading NF figures, John Tyndall and Martin Webster. The appearance of Tyndall in full nazi uniform, drawn from the archives of Searchlight, was a key part of ANL propaganda, coupled with deeply damaging nazi quotes from Webster.

Paul Holborow
Founding member of the ANL and National Organiser 1977-81

Nick Davies

Nick Davies

To investigate fascists takes real courage and unusual commitment. The government, police, mainstream media occasionally take a look, but in the UK only Searchlight have kept at it, relentlessly and admirably, regardless of threat or obstacle. It’s journalism that matters. A rare thing.

Nick Davies
Multi-award-winning investigative journalist and writer

Peter Hain

Peter Hain, founder of the ANL and friend of Searchlight

British Jews have been persecuted over the centuries; British blacks since the Windrush generation of the 1950s; British Muslims, especially after the Islamist 9/11 and then 7/7 terrorist attacks in New York 2001 and London 2005. But until the last few years there has not been a simultaneous threat against all three British communities of Jewish, Black and Muslim Britons – meaning the need for Searchlight has never been greater.

Peter Hain
Labour peer, former MP and Cabinet Minster

Paul Nowak

Paul Nowak

The essence of trade unionism is solidarity, fairness and equality – for all workers – from all backgrounds. That’s why our fight against the far-right has always been part of our movement’s DNA. Searchlight is an incredibly important resource for trade unions and members to understand the contemporary tactics of far-right activity. Their work and intelligence gathering over the years have been incredibly insightful for the work we do, and how we fight the scourge of fascism.

Paul Nowak
TUC General Secretary

Alf Dubs

Lord Alf Dubs

Searchlight’s voice is more important than ever, and I am delighted that it will now be available to a wider audience than ever before in its new incarnation online. Searchlight has been extremely helpful over the years in exposing the far right, corruption, criminality and the murky links between organised crime and powerful interests in the UK and abroad. I wish Searchlight the very best.

Alf Dubs
Labour peer, former MP and Cabinet Minister, and Kindertransport child

Top ten most read

3 responses to “Patriotic Alternative running scared after trial reveals terrorist link”

  1. Matt Hale is in prison on a forty year stretch. Even we CREATORS believe him to be a psychopath, but forty years? Five years would have been the correct sentence. Also, the US government anti-terrorism laws did not come in until after Hale was initially arrested. His charges were enhanced after the creation of those laws. Even Jewish lawyers at the time questioned Hale’s treatment.

    Another point, Hale has not had any responsibility for any part of Creativity in more than twenty years. His Creativity Movement no longer exists, and we in the Creativity Alliance – Church of Creativity certainly want nothing at all to do with Hale.

    As for James Costello, he attempted to do the right and lawful thing by straightening out Hale’s thugs. And he more or less succeeded. James does not deserve to spend a single day behind bars, never mind five years. James’ conviction was a travesty of justice. The police and courts have better things they should be doing.

  2. Archbishop Peedo the Pale

    Are you the Cailen Cambeul who was an “outlaw biker” before you “channeled your natural aggression” to less illegal but more profitable activities, including association with the “Church of Creativity”, sounds so similar to the “Church of the Creator”, and assumed, to complement your inventive ”Reverend”, the title of “Pontifex Maximus Emeritus” (2009-2016) and maybe other meaningless, grandiose mumbojumbo which impress suckers?

    Who could fail to be convinced by
    “If there is one thing in this wonderful world of ours that is worth preserving, defending, and promoting, it is the White Race. Nature looked fondly upon the White Race and lavished special loving care in (sic) its growth. Of all the millions of creatures who have inhabited the face of this planet over the eons of time (sic), none has ever quite equaled that of the White Race. Nature endowed her Elite with a greater abundance of intelligence and creativity, of energy and productivity than she endowed unto any other creature, now or in the millenniums past. It has been the White Race who has been the world builder, the makers of cities and commerce and continents. It is the White Man who is the sole builder of civilizations. It was he who built the Egyptian civilization (sic) …” ?

    Weblink to where it shows you promoting that and other wisdom in the White Man’s Bible.available on request.

  3. Virginia Golden

    Alex Davies, not Mark Davies. How can you get such simple things wrong?